We proudly serve Northeast Florida with three locations in Jacksonville, Fleming Island, and Ponte Vedra Beach. Each store features a curated butcher counter, dry-aged selections, signature sausages, gourmet pantry favorites, smoked specialties and lots more.

Yes — shop in-store for personalized butcher service or order online for convenient delivery options or in-store pickup.

Absolutely. In addition to premium beef, pork, chicken, and exotics, we offer Amish pantry staples, award winning sauces, pickles, jams, farm butter, raw cheeses, baked goods, and gourmet grocery selections.

Yes — digital and physical gift cards are available, along with curated meat bundles that make impressive gifts for holidays, chefs, and grill lovers.

Our beef is proudly sourced from top-tier domestic farms in the U.S., primarily from the Midwest — including Iowa, Nebraska, and Colorado. We specialize in Certified Angus Beef, Wagyu, and select grass-fed beef options, chosen for exceptional marbling, tenderness, and flavor.

Yes — we carry premium grass-fed beef cuts as well as naturally pasture-raised exotics like venison, bison, and elk. We also source free-range poultry and thoughtfully raised duck.

Yes — our poultry is raised without antibiotics or added hormones, meeting strict U.S. standards for purity and safety.

We proudly carry Halal-certified lamb and goat. For special requests, contact our customer support team.

Yes — we dry-age select steaks in-house using a controlled environment to deepen flavor, enhance tenderness, and create the signature richness prized by steak connoisseurs.

Absolutely — custom cuts are available daily at the counter, or call ahead to request specialty butchery or thickness preferences.

Yes — we offer premium freezer bundles designed to stock your home with chef-quality meats at exceptional value. Contact us directly for custom bundle options.

Yes — we offer wild game processing services. Please call your nearest store for details and scheduling.

Browse our online menu, select your items, and check out securely. Choose local pickup or delivery options at checkout.

Yes — although online ordering offers the fastest and most accurate experience, our support team is happy to take phone orders.

Yes — we provide next-business-day refrigerated delivery from all three locations to surrounding Northeast Florida areas. Delivery options and pricing appear at checkout.

All orders are vacuum-sealed, temperature-protected, and packed with insulated cold-chain materials to maintain peak quality during transit.

We accept all major credit cards, debit cards, Tillman’s gift cards, and cash in-store.

Yes — we accept pre-approved corporate checks in-store only.

Yes — you may split your purchase between a gift card and another payment method.

No — Tillman’s gift cards never expire.

Refrigerate immediately and cook within 2–3 days. If not cooking right away, freeze upon purchase. Vacuum-sealed meats freeze exceptionally well.

Beef: up to 12 monthsPork: up to 6 monthsChicken: up to 9 months

Thaw in the refrigerator for best results. For faster thawing, submerge vacuum-sealed meat in cold water, changing the water every 30 minutes. Never thaw at room temperature.

Contact us immediately via phone or our contact form and we’ll correct the order promptly.

Our cold-chain packaging protects your order, but if there's ever an issue, simply contact us with photos and your order number. We stand behind every order.

Due to food safety standards, returns are not accepted — but if anything is unsatisfactory, we will replace it or arrange a solution.